Partially Open Fields as the Energy Bounds for Solar Eruptions: Comparison with MHD Models

Authors: Jon A. Linker (Predictive Science Inc.), Cooper Downs (Predictive Science Inc.), Ronald M. Caplan (Predictive Science Inc.), Tibor Torok (Predictive Science Inc.), Viacheslav Titov (Predictive Science Inc.)

The energy source for major solar eruptions, such as flares and coronal mass ejections (CMEs), is recognized to originate in the solar magnetic field. Specifically, it is believed to be the release of the free magnetic energy (energy above the potential field state) stored in the field prior to eruption. A key question for both predicting future eruptions and estimating their possible magnitude is, what is the bound to this energy?

The Aly-Sturrock theorem shows that the energy of a fully force-free field cannot exceed the energy of the so-called open field. If the theorem holds, this places an upper limit on the amount of free energy that can be stored. This is not a practical limit, as even the largest CMEs open only a portion of the coronal magnetic field. The energy of a closely related field, the partially open field (POF), is believed to provide the corresponding limit for a localized region, such as an active region. We have developed practical methods for estimating the POF energy (POFE). We test these estimates by comparing them with the maximum energy storage achieved in MHD simulations of three different regions that were the site of significant solar eruptions (July 14, 2000, March 7, 2012, and October 1, 2011).

Research supported by NASA and NSF.